Jump to content

Health Care in the UK vs Australia


Marisawright

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 98
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted Images

So much whinging Paul. You should move home... Must be awful to be so upset all the time, or are you just a serial complainer wherever you are?

I am moving home.. Got my plan and time frame.. Your life can't be too smart, you spend all day everyday on here talking about a country you don't live in

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I am moving home.. Got my plan and time frame.. Your life can't be too smart, you spend all day everyday on here talking about a country you don't live in

 

I'm at work :wink:. Perfectly happy thanks hence I don't need to blame a country for my woes.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

no health service is free (maybe Cuba?)

but this is my heath care in WA last month:

doctor appointment (we have no bulk bills) $38 but x two as needed two = $76

Prescription = = 85 I actually needs another two mess including a statin but I simply can't afford them

chest X-ray = $224

 

next month nth and probably the month after even these will not happen as I simply don't have the cash. None were claimable on Medicare or private.

We will have to drop our private health cover in the next couple of months. At which point, I will no longer be able to afford an ambulance for a heart attack - oh and two of the drugs I can no longer afford are to prevent it. So, I suspect 2015 maybe my bow out.

Do you get a PBS Safety Net card at the beginning of each calendar year where you keep the stickers from the pharmacy each time you or anyone in your family has a prescription filled? We do and from about June or July every year, our cost per prescription drops to (at present) $6 from the usual $38. And have you registered with Medicare for the Medicare Safety net for your family. You've probably done both things but I've been surprised at how few people know that the safety nets exist.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

no health service is free (maybe Cuba?)

but this is my heath care in WA last month:

doctor appointment (we have no bulk bills) $38 but x two as needed two = $76

Prescription = = 85 I actually needs another two mess including a statin but I simply can't afford them

chest X-ray = $224

 

next month nth and probably the month after even these will not happen as I simply don't have the cash. None were claimable on Medicare or private.

We will have to drop our private health cover in the next couple of months. At which point, I will no longer be able to afford an ambulance for a heart attack - oh and two of the drugs I can no longer afford are to prevent it. So, I suspect 2015 maybe my bow out.

 

This is an issue which continues to worry me. As an IT contractor I'm in and out of work and luckily have built up some savings now. But 18 months ago, work was thin on the ground and although I needed to go to the Drs, I didn't feel that we could justify the expense. As it was at the time we were hit with around $4K 'out of pocket' health expenses on top of what we had to pay for medical insurance. Not eligible for any benefit when I'm out of work as hubby works, albeit in quite a low paid profession. I definitely view healthcare as a bit of a luxury here. Great value for those that can afford it. if you're not flush and you're not skint sometimes you fall outside the net and have to prioritise, and for parents especially that can mean going without GP visits and medication.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This is an issue which continues to worry me. As an IT contractor I'm in and out of work and luckily have built up some savings now. But 18 months ago, work was thin on the ground and although I needed to go to the Drs, I didn't feel that we could justify the expense. As it was at the time we were hit with around $4K 'out of pocket' health expenses on top of what we had to pay for medical insurance. Not eligible for any benefit when I'm out of work as hubby works, albeit in quite a low paid profession. I definitely view healthcare as a bit of a luxury here. Great value for those that can afford it. if you're not flush and you're not skint sometimes you fall outside the net and have to prioritise, and for parents especially that can mean going without GP visits and medication.

 

Here in Sydney it's fairly easy to find a GP that bulk-bills. If you need specialist care, the public system is good - you just need to prompt the GP that you don't have health insurance and they will send you to a public specialist. My husband has never had health insurance in his life and rarely pays a cent for anything.

 

The health funds in Australia do a marvellous job of scaring everyone into thinking they need insurance and that waiting lists are horrendous if you don't have it. However it's not true. I had a spinal fusion last year - even with health insurance, I was out of pocket about $10,000. However it was an important op and I comforted myself that I was able to get the best of care sooner than in the public health system.

 

Then my friend's dad needed the same op, but he has no insurance so he went through the public system. He was booked in about a month later, and it cost him the grand total of $2,000.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest littlesarah
Here in Sydney it's fairly easy to find a GP that bulk-bills. If you need specialist care, the public system is good - you just need to prompt the GP that you don't have health insurance and they will send you to a public specialist. My husband has never had health insurance in his life and rarely pays a cent for anything.

 

The health funds in Australia do a marvellous job of scaring everyone into thinking they need insurance and that waiting lists are horrendous if you don't have it. However it's not true. I had a spinal fusion last year - even with health insurance, I was out of pocket about $10,000. However it was an important op and I comforted myself that I was able to get the best of care sooner than in the public health system.

 

Then my friend's dad needed the same op, but he has no insurance so he went through the public system. He was booked in about a month later, and it cost him the grand total of $2,000.

 

I think it depends on what procedure you need. For some procedures, it's best to get someone with that sub-specialty if you want to maximise your chances of a good outcome, and for that you may find that you have to pay.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Here in Sydney it's fairly easy to find a GP that bulk-bills. If you need specialist care, the public system is good - you just need to prompt the GP that you don't have health insurance and they will send you to a public specialist. My husband has never had health insurance in his life and rarely pays a cent for anything.

 

The health funds in Australia do a marvellous job of scaring everyone into thinking they need insurance and that waiting lists are horrendous if you don't have it. However it's not true. I had a spinal fusion last year - even with health insurance, I was out of pocket about $10,000. However it was an important op and I comforted myself that I was able to get the best of care sooner than in the public health system.

 

Then my friend's dad needed the same op, but he has no insurance so he went through the public system. He was booked in about a month later, and it cost him the grand total of $2,000.

what would happen to someone who had no money?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest littlesarah
what would happen to someone who had no money?

 

Presumably they wouldn't have health insurance anyway, so they'd go via the public system, like the person in the last paragraph (and if they had a healthcare card may well not have to pay even the $2000)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Presumably they wouldn't have health insurance anyway, so they'd go via the public system, like the person in the last paragraph (and if they had a healthcare card may well not have to pay even the $2000)

what if they were out of work earned very little and could not afford health insurance?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

what if they were out of work earned very little and could not afford health insurance?

 

I figured you would know this from your time in Perth. Or was it Perth in Scotland? I'm totally confused now

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

A quick reply:

 

I have worked in hospitals here after working in the UK NHS/Military for 15 years. After leaving Defence last year I started nursing in Private sector hospitals. I was so shocked at how behind the UK the Australian health sector is. Basic best practice in UK is not adhered to in Australia and medical management is poor to say the very least, cleanliness and good nursing care is not governed well at all in Australia.

 

I do love it here but certainly not regarding health. I left the Private sector and went to where my heart lay. I have now started a masters in mental health and clinical counselling and moved to mental health in Illawarra and I am enjoying it. We are aiming to move to the UK in 2017 after 8 years in Oz. One of the main reasons for us is the poor state of healthcare treatment even when we have top notch private. I am more shocked that your husband presumes the UK would be behind Private healthcare in Oz. Profits and healthcare can not coexist and create good healthcare for patients. The NHS was a fantastic organisation with excellent outcomes and clinical parameters underpinned by evidence based practice.

 

Good luck.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

A quick reply:

 

I have worked in hospitals here after working in the UK NHS/Military for 15 years. After leaving Defence last year I started nursing in Private sector hospitals. I was so shocked at how behind the UK the Australian health sector is.

 

Shouldn't you qualify that statement with "at the hospitals I worked in" and/or "in the private sector"?

 

All the Nurses that I know in Qld Health public sector prefer the Qld public health sector to the NHS..................for the many reasons that have been posted before.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

A quick reply:

 

I have worked in hospitals here after working in the UK NHS/Military for 15 years. After leaving Defence last year I started nursing in Private sector hospitals. I was so shocked at how behind the UK the Australian health sector is. Basic best practice in UK is not adhered to in Australia and medical management is poor to say the very least, cleanliness and good nursing care is not governed well at all in Australia.

 

I do love it here but certainly not regarding health. I left the Private sector and went to where my heart lay. I have now started a masters in mental health and clinical counselling and moved to mental health in Illawarra and I am enjoying it. We are aiming to move to the UK in 2017 after 8 years in Oz. One of the main reasons for us is the poor state of healthcare treatment even when we have top notch private. I am more shocked that your husband presumes the UK would be behind Private healthcare in Oz. Profits and healthcare can not coexist and create good healthcare for patients. The NHS was a fantastic organisation with excellent outcomes and clinical parameters underpinned by evidence based practice.

 

Good luck.

Heard it many times on here that the NHS is far better than the aussie equivalent, we knock the NHS but when you work overseas you appreciate how good it is on your return.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


×
×
  • Create New...