Ok. I started this and I may as well put on the 100th comment (thanks for all the differing opinions btw).
This question has bugged me the last couple of days and made me think.
As far as I see it, there are 2 types of immigrants. Asylum and economic.
The asylum seekers are fleeing a really crappy situation in their home country. This can be due to race, religion, political view or sexual orientation. These people deserve our help and support (whichever country we're in) because we are all human beings who should have a right to a peaceful and happy life.
The economic migrants, such as myself, are looking to improve their life. This can be fiscal or intrinsic. Unfortunately some economic migrants pretend to be asylum seekers through greed or a lack of compassion for people in genuine need of help.
Stopping the boat people from getting into Australia could stop the false asylum seekers from attempting the journey. It could also remind the genuine asylum seekers that there are ways of making applications for asylum without having to risk their lives.
As a bonus, it would also cut off the income for the scumbags that are human traffickers. Profiting from the desperation of people in need surely makes them the lowest of the low.
So, in my opinion.. It probably is a good idea in the long term.
It's just a shame that its been introduced by politicians, the people who, in my moral scale, rank as low as human traffickers.
The best things in life aren't things.