Lu Ding

Applied Sep 2019. Nothing yet. 
They are still processing 2018 files. 

2 hours ago, Parimal said:

Is anybody got any news from AAT who lodged the application in October 2019?

I lodged in September 2019, no news yet.  

32 minutes ago, Caltex said:

Hlo guys , i m a silent follower of this page , applied MRT in sep2019 as a retail manager nd today My employer received email to provide documents . 

Hi, I am also applied in Sep 2019 as a retail manager but still no news. It's kind of scaring me that they open your file so fast and that means they could open my file anytime soon. but I am not ready yet. pls keep us updated and wish you all the best. The waiting is over for you 

1 hour ago, Vijay avichal said:

waiting AAT APPLIED  January 2018, RSMS, 187 DE, RETAIL MANAGER, QLD STILL WAITING for, ANY IDEA WHEN IT WILL OPEN, 

RSMS DE QLD 187 Retail Manager
Nomination and Visa August 2016
Nomination AND VISA refused January 2018
AAT FOR NOMINATION ADN VISA -JAN 2018

STILL WAITING

I applied in 2019 , the waiting is killing me.  Also retail manager , QLD. 

1 hour ago, anandjose90 said:

Hi is there anyone in this forum whose 187 visa has been rejected and waiting for AAT decision. If so how long?. I have been waiting for 25 months for AAT decision.

Hi, I applied AAT last year in Sep and still waiting. 
 

I know most of people are waiting for 20-24 Months. I believe yours is coming soon.  
 

1 minute ago, David08 said:

Hi guys,

Hope everyone is doing well, just the update following the hearing.

Application July 2017

Nomination Refusal March 2018

AAT Application April 2019

AAT requested documents: 24th Feb 2020

Hearing Scheduled: 12th May 2020

Further Documents: 19th May 2020

Nomination Approved: 27th May

I wish everyone best of luck, I will let you guys know once we hear from immigration for the next process so everyone has a rough idea.

 

 

Hi, David,

Congratulations for your nomination!

May I ask what is your position and what was the reason for refusal? 
 

Thanks

43 minutes ago, Greyz said:

Hi guys

Silent follower whose nomination was approved. 187 DR Onshore

Application May 2018

Nomination Refusal May 2019

AAT Application May 2019

AAT requested documents Apr 2020

Hearing May 2020 

Nomination approved and remitted to Immi

Hi, congratulations!!!!

But May I ask you’ve been only waiting for 1 year from AAT ? I am still expecting 2 years waiting. 
 

Can I ask What is your occupation and what was the reason for the refusal? 
 

Thank you

11 minutes ago, wait fr gd said:

yes next week on phone

 

Ok! Please Let us know after the hearing. I wish you the best luck  

9 minutes ago, wait fr gd said:

same here, i quit the job after 7 months and apply new visa but now have hearing but employer provide docs and ready to go fr hearing, rest on almighty of god.

Hi, May I ask when is your hearing ? 

14 hours ago, Your Highness said:

Hi all,

I've been silent follower of this group for a very long time. These are my details.

RSMS applied: May 2016 (Nomination & visa)

Retail Manager - Victoria region

Refused: 28th December 2017.

Reason for refusal: My employer have more than one store and case officer thought my owner is running businesses without any sponsored employee before and he can continue doing that & doesn't need any sponsored manager. (Which is of course a weird reason to refuse and they just did it as they did it to many other RSMS applicants in that period)

AAT lodged: February 2018.

AAT hearing: Nomination & Visa on 9th October 2019. Nomination hearing took around 40 minutes, followed by Visa hearing less than 10 minutes.

Member asked my employer number of questions about business, employer profile, applicant details and other employees. At the end of hearing member asked my employer to submit latest financials, training and Salaries related documents.

Documents submitted on 22nd of October 2019.

Decision: Set aside on 6th December 2019 both Nomination & Visa.

Regards.

I wish "All The Best" to everyone.

Thank you

 

Congratulations! !! 
May I ask about training and salaries documents , were they asking for everyone’s? Or just yours? 

18 hours ago, AmberD said:

Hi Lu Ding,

Yes, we waited for that long! I didn't expect this at all. Do you have any suggestions what could be done?

If your employer withdraw the nomination appeal, there is really nothing you can do except talking with your employer. Otherwise, you might need to find another sponsor.  That’s what I think. 

5 hours ago, AmberD said:

Hi All,

My employer has withdraw the application with AAT for nomination refusal which was applied in 2017. I am on bridging visa A currently. My employer didn't ask/inform before taking this crucial step. Now I have given 2 weeks to comment on the situation. Can anyone suggest what to do or have heard or gone thru the similar situation? Please help

I am sorry to hear that. But why your employer withdraw the application which you already waited for almost 2 years????? And without inform you ???  That soundS really bad to me.  

21 hours ago, tatamaru said:

Finished my AAT hearing on 10/10, that was the worst experience I’ve ever had in my life. The member didn’t even question anything about the refusal reason listed by the immigration, instead, he was questioning the business itself the whole time and based on his unprofessional accounting knowledge, he was arguing about the superannuation calculation method on our financial report  made by our professional accountant. We realised he was wrong after the hearing but during the hearing he wouldn’t let us to prove there is no problem on the financial report by contact the accountant. Now this reason ended up being the reason AAT refused my visa.

Hi, may I ask did they actually just used “ Super calculation problems “ to reject you?  ? I was thinking about your case the whole day I just couldn’t understand.  
 

what is exactly wrong with the financial report? Why they got confused with super part? 

35 minutes ago, MilaMocha said:

They didn’t say someone else was the manager?

they said the manager is owner 

3 hours ago, MilaMocha said:

Why? Based on the Org chart? If so, who else was listed on it?

Based on job description and franchise agreement 

2 minutes ago, Jayjay16 said:

Chef, refused reason: financial 

Ok, Thank you. 
mine is retail manager. Reason; supervisor not manager 

5 minutes ago, Jayjay16 said:

Yes it will be at the bottom of the letter. 

 

Yes, they asked for evidence of salary paid to me, tax returns and PAYG , and superannuation statements. 

Hi, may I ask what is your occupation and what was the reason the IMMI officer reject you ? 

9 minutes ago, Jayjay16 said:

After we submitted docs for the first request, nearly 1 month later they sent an invite for the hearing(15/11) , then few days ago they requested more docs again. We going to submit tomorrow and see what will happen next.

Please keep us updated. Everyone in this group we are not the lucky ones. I’ve seen some people got their PR in 1 month or 4 months. Even my friend who submitted at the same time with me and he got approved, I just got rejected. So we have to be strong and stay together and fight for this. 

6 minutes ago, tatamaru said:

I can’t apply for another visa while I’m still on my bridging visa A and if I don’t apply for another appealing I will have to leave in 28 days. Also I might not be able to come back by applying a new visa from oversea because I have this refusal history. I have to try the higher court.

The higher court costs more money. But in your case , it might worths to t try it. Because it sounds like the member was not professional and rude to you. 
 

so basically, they just use “ The company cannot afford you” as new reason to reject your nomination? 
 

I understand that they will got confused about like “ Company are running in loss or Other financial problems” but why they confused with super ???? It is in your contact and your payslip. Why they got confused about super calculation.  

7 hours ago, tatamaru said:

Finished my AAT hearing on 10/10, that was the worst experience I’ve ever had in my life. The member didn’t even question anything about the refusal reason listed by the immigration, instead, he was questioning the business itself the whole time and based on his unprofessional accounting knowledge, he was arguing about the superannuation calculation method on our financial report  made by our professional accountant. We realised he was wrong after the hearing but during the hearing he wouldn’t let us to prove there is no problem on the financial report by contact the accountant. Now this reason ended up being the reason AAT refused my visa.

I am so sorry to hear that, heartbroken. Yes, my MA also said , the Member is very important.  It will influence the results directly. I feel sorry for you. 

7 hours ago, Jayjay16 said:

Refused because of the financial ability.

I think they want to see you if your employer Pays you as manager pay ( correct payment). If he has been paid you for last 2 or 3 years , then you should fine. 

2 hours ago, Jayjay16 said:

Hi everyone, I am new here and would like to ask if anyone in the same situation with me. My employer applied AAT in October 2017 and my visa application on November 2017. Early September 2019 my employer got a request for more docs letter from AAT ( recent financial docs) we submitted within 1 week. After that, 6th October they sent out a date for my employer nomination’s hearing(15/11) and then today they againrequested more paperwork ( evidence of my salary, bank statement, tax returns). And they want it to be submit before 25/10. Is it normal? Thanks

Hi, can I please ask what was the reason they reject your nomination? 
 

I hope the best for you

Retail manager 

time line : 

nomination and visa : 22 Feb, 2018

nomination refused : 04/sep, 2019 

reason:  supervisor not a manager ( we are franchise, CO thinks we just follow the franchise agreement so I am not actually doing manager job) 

location: Far North Queensland 

AAT nomination lodged: 23 Sep, 2019 

still waiting for visa refuse and going to lodge visa appeal as well. 

Changed a different MA 

Hoping for a miracle......

1 hour ago, Rajat Babbar said:

Hello everyone,
With gloomy heart I would like to to confess that my nomination has been rejected after 29 months.

My timeline
RCB : Mar 2017
Nom: Apr 2017
Visa: Aug 2017
S56 request: Oct 2018
Status : Further assessment
Reason : No reason given

Ques 1: Guys can you please help me. Someone told me that Overseas people cannot apply for AAT is it true? But they gave me a option to apply.

Ques 2: How long is the current wait at AAT ?

Ques 3: How much % chances are that nomination can get approved ?

Ques 4: Do we get 21 days or 28 days to apply for AAT .. ita little confusing..

My status is still showing Further assessment.

Please guide me if you had similar case
I will appreciate that.

Thanks
 

Hey, the Current AAT waiting is 12-18 months. But in reality, I think it is 2 years.  

I looked into the percentages of AAT wining , it is 26% winning about 186 , 187 appeal. ( the highest percentage  is partner visa appeal which is 50%).  But you still need to know the reason. 

You have to lodge the AAT in 21 days. 

I think they cannot reject a nomination without a reason. ( but if Your nomination got refused, then your visa will be rejected automatically  without any specific reason ). 

So I am not sure if they reject your nomination without any reason or just reject your visa? 

Just now, Lu Ding said:

Sorry to hear you got nomination rejected. But they should give you a reason.  Even it’s a stupid reason. Can I ask what’s your occupation ? 

And are you going for tribunal?