Deep1984

2 hours ago, parveen said:

From july 2018 further assessment and nomination not approved yet

Occupation and timeline

1 hour ago, npnglife said:

hi guys,

I got a bad news from my agent this morning.

The nomination refused yesterday and I have two options.

1. withdrawal

2. appeal after 28 days

I waited 19 months and I really expected my visa going to be approve this month.

However, I shocked with this result.

 

My agent recommend me that I choose option 2 because it will be success that if company appeals after 28 days.

But he doesn't say how long does it take.

 

Is there anyone had this experience?

 

Occupation plz and reason

6 hours ago, Jharvey said:

It's my third time applying for my permanent residency. 

 

 Previous two times applying the business nomination has been refused.

Big congrats jharvey  I applied 2nd time still received

On 26/01/2019 at 11:35, Kashif.Iqbal said:

hi guys,

i have a query, which application is more quicker 186 TRT or 187 TRT?

Please answer

Depend on luck. Every day u have new question . 

37 minutes ago, SAJ.N said:

Does anybody know why on my IMMI account shows  for medical exam ,provided  no action required while we haven't done any medical test for our new application.

The only thing is last time that our nomination got refusal we had medical in the system.

Who knows how to get a new HAP ID?

If u applied new application then on the basis of new appl.u will get new HAP ID. Everything new like TRN no. 

On 15/05/2018 at 23:47, Xxaz said:

Omg! After 1 year AAT and still nothing??!! I will be crazy as well like you.. during this 1 year AAT do u need to go for any hearing or court? But your 457 still active 

2 hours ago, Hex said:

I'm also not familiar with the HR and LR occupations.

- The only one I know that is HR (from this forum), is `Restaurant Manager`

Perhaps someone has a link to the different sets for us all? 

Cook which category HR OR LR

11 minutes ago, VS01 said:

My medical expired in October 2018 and I was expecting my VISA in May 2019. Planning to renew my medical, should I used the same HAP ID which was taken up by IMMI account. My previous VISA medical was valid when the application was submitted hence system have not generated new HAP ID.    Currently, I have the HAP ID letter which was generated for 457 VISA, should I use the same to schedule the medical appointment?

When did u applied?

10 hours ago, Pottsie said:

Just a thought on the nomination process, Do all employers have to provide an organizational chart for 186/187?

 

Yes its must.  To be a safe

Just now, 187visa refusal said:

I still didn’t got it but it may be less profit 

U can see other agents opinion. What they said. In my case I reapplied,  I got refusal ENS 186 TRT reason genuine position and didnt provide organization chart. My MA told to reapply again. 

35 minutes ago, 187visa refusal said:

And after then what ?

because they already send me a nomination refusal 

i am stuck I have no idea what should I do ? 

Do I have Left any positive side ?

What's reason to refuse?

I have no idea about aat . AAT take more than 2 year. U still dont know about reason why they refuse.  Try to find reason from  ur MA. 

On 22/12/2018 at 07:58, 187visa refusal said:

Does I have any other option?

I pretty sure ur MA send refusal letter to employer. Immi. After refuse nomination they send 2 letter to MA.

1. Invitation to commont on information for ENS visa nominations  refuse. ( u got this one) 

2. Notification of refusal of a application. ( this one get only employer and MA.

SECOND letter most of the agent not provide to client because this belong to employer under confidentiality information.

U have to request to ur MA To provide one.

6 hours ago, 187visa refusal said:

They did refuse without providing reasons 

 

so so what does that mean ?

We dont know until see ur letter. Post ur letter to us which u got from immi. We will see and tell you if u coudnt find reason in the letter.

16 minutes ago, Vipa23 said:

HI CCP,

So sorry to hear about your situation. My reply might be too late now as I just found your post today.However I just wanna share my case.

My case is exactly the same as you. I got my nomination refused in June2018(Ens186 Pastrycook transits from 457). The reasons of refusal was that there was insufficient evidence (receipts, a written report of the training outcome) to show that PR or Citizen were giving training. After having consultations from 2 migration agents and 2 migration lawyers,then I decided to reapply as those migration specialists said there is the best option for me so far. The positive point for reapply option is that  the laws have chance. So.if you lodge a nomination application after 12 August 2018 the case officer are now not required to assess the training benchmark requirements as all businesses that nominate permanent or temporary staff must simply pay the training contribution charge( $3,000 for business with a turnover  less than 10 million.

Anyway my case still has risks as the refusal decision of the previous nomination is on record and it could be adverse information and this can affect to the new nomination so the best way to do is providing  a strong submission about the previous training issue. Or if I'm lucky , the case officer might not give  weight to the training benchmark issue on the record as it has been discarded by the new laws. Finger cross and always have a good hope! 

What I want to tell you is that don't just stick on one migration agent but seek a lot of second opinions from several agents or even lawyers to ensure you get the best solution. Good luck! 

I reapply  my new application because old nomination refuse june 2018 reason genuine position. New application lodge Aug. Reapply is better option rather than go to appeal. 

19 hours ago, Bips22 said:

Same here been 10 plus years in Aus .....

Same here 11 year

4 hours ago, qfmouse said:

I`m feeling the same with you.

Just like you, my first nomination got refused in Feb 2018 which applied in Nov 2017.

It`s amazing that only take 3 months to get a CO even my occupation has removed from the list since 457 reform in Apr 2017.

They just rejected me on genuine need and org chart.

So it`s really hard to admit they have a pattern.

 

Same here June 2017 got nomination refusal stright way reason genuine need and org. Chart. Reapply again aus.2018. Hopefully I will get this time

5 hours ago, eccc said:

How long have you waited for the anwer from the immigraton department? 

I applied In June 2018 for ministerial intervention review.

Reply from immigration on 12 November 2018

On 27/10/2018 at 03:47, Mano@187 said:

Expect in next couple of months. 

I reply from immigration related to ministerial intervention review. They refused my visa old ens 186 visa because I applied new application. In August. I applied for ministerial intervention review in June 2018 and got result in Nov. They not going to review old decision like refusal nomination.

1 hour ago, Shilla Lucky said:

i know right?? i am also interested to know because this will be a record breaker.

May be mistake in dates like wrong date.  I interested to know as well

3 hours ago, SR012 said:

Hi Naj,

your training benchmark should be paid for 2018 as well ,please contact your MA to discuss -there are two ways of complying the training bench mark 

Those whose alredy paid SAF levy fund by employer which file lodged after 12 August 2018 still need benchmark?

9 hours ago, Manpreet kaur1 said:

Hi guys 

I want some help 

my nomination is refused 

Now want to apply 489 visa so I need a job offer latter in regional area , if you know about any job of cook in Queensland then plz text me.plz take it seriously 

What was the reason and occupation and lodged date?

11 hours ago, Eddy101 said:

Yes let us all hope our turn will come soon!

Which month they are processing now?

6 hours ago, Mano@187 said:

Probably Around 6 months. 

One my friend did it in april still didnt hearing anything from immi.

On 11/10/2018 at 00:56, Mano@187 said:

I am not very confident too . Usually minister don't intervene in most of the cases . So end of the day decision is still unchanged. There is no doubt you worked hard to get to the big decision but chances are not too bright with the ministerial intervention. 

I think for ministerial intervention you only have to wait about six months.

You can try your luck with ministerial intervention but you should have other plans too in case decision does not come in your favour. Best of luck.

How long process for intervene review (ministerisl intervention) ?