Xxaz

Hi there can you please share what did you provide or explain during the hearing? I will have my hearing in April

I receive my invitation for hearing finally after waiting for 32 months... can anybody share what to expect during the hearing ? What did they ask ?

Hi if anyone still following this...  25 February 2021 I got my invitation for the hearing. I don’t know what to do

On 27/01/2020 at 22:05, ram4 said:

hello everyone,

• I m new in this forum. I lodged my AAT for nomination and visa in Aug 2017. immigration officer visited my workplace. my job designation not matched with the business card. they refused nomination on the ground of business card and i  m not present on the workplace as well on that day. I left my job after completion of 5 years on 457 visa. now my file open for aat and my AAT hearing on 10 Feb 2020. my employer wants to submit docs for AAT hearing but he refuses to attend a hearing. I am in stress and confusion, is worth to go for hearing for me and my family. because nomination and visa hearing are on same day. please help me in this situation, you guys have more knowledge than me. 

Hi Rama, hope you are well? I’m in similar situations like your, working for 7 years for the same employee (3yr student visa +4 year 457) and 186 refuse because of financial on May 2018 then apply for aat.

june 2019 I quit from my job and get a new job in different company as I was on BR.

I wondering how is your hearing goes? Did you advice aat when you change your job?

did you get the approval?

thank you 

Hi everyone, i wonder if anyone on the similar situation as mine and if can give me a piece of advice or knowledge. i know there's a lot of mistake that has happen during my application but im looking for a solution or advice if you could share your info. I've believe most people in this forum have been through the stress and pressure with this australia immigration thingy  Thank you

Background :

I had been worked for the same company over 7 year in total ,(3 year using student visa + 4 year under 457 visa )

on 2017 -  my lawyer apply for my 186 visa with an explanation my company (*ABC) is changing to another business model (*XYZ), but my immigration lawyer didnt apply a 457 transfer from ABC to XYZ for me, which result into  186 refusal on May 2018 because my company change their business model and using different name and ABN. So immigration cant find any connection between those 2 company and the new company is not making profit.

I apply for AAT on June 2018 , with a letter from my manager explaining both company is connected and the reason why the new company is not yet making profit and providing the projection the profit the company will be making in the future.

Now, my 457 has been expired (June 2019) and im holding bridging visa A. 

August 2019, i start a new job in new company with my bridging visa A.

I still havent hear anything from my ATT application which i have apply on June 2018.

im not using any migration agent anynore for my AAT Case.

did anyone got their AAT approve after their change to another company?

as I'm not working on the company i apply for the appeal meaning i dont have any hope any more for my appeal case?

Do i need to notify AAT or immigration that i change to new company?

@Yuyu Hi Yuyu i wonder if you already get a result of your AAT? did you get your PR yet??

Hi Yuyu... be prepare for the worst... case with aat we never know... i cant imagine myself in your position in next year... but Please stay strong.. if you already done everything you could have done, just pray for the best....

Lets hope this new financial year will bring a new luck for us

Hi i just applied my aat for visa refusal yesterday, i had applied for my nomination refusal earlier.. but i wonder if anyone knows what documents i needed to put on my visa document for the AAT? since im apply AAT without immigration agent / immigration lawyer. any advise will be very much appreciated. Thank you

Hi @declanchou can I ask when u decide to appeal do u need to prepare all the document form the beginning when u apply for the 186? Or just prepare the document regarding the excuse of the refusal to aat?

also, did u prepare the document before submitting your aat, or after aat open the case and request the document then you submitt it? 

Me and my employer thinking to do the aat without using the migration agent.

Thank you

Sorry to confuse you with "financial year 2017"

I apply on june 2017, so we only submit for the 2016 only, so 1 months ago my MA ask my employer to submit the financial statement ended June 2017. Since the company is expanding the company is making loss because they are spending lots of money to grow the business. 

the financial statement was sent directly from my employer to MA, I wasn't informed it's state making loss..not that I need to know how much it's losing etc.,, but at least I could ask them to write an explanation or at least I be aware it might be refuse ect And be prepare.,,

My MA should have ask my employer to write the financial viability statement when submitting the financial statement but he didn't....

My reason for refusal was Financial loss because my company now is expanding and they are making loss on the financial year 2017...

@declanchou hi!! Congratulations!!! So happy to hear there's people who get approve via aat.....can u share us what is the reason of you refusal ? 

1 hour ago, cristinamia said:

Hi @cristinamia I'm just trying to understand why reapply instead of aat ? Isn't  go through aat is one step closer than reapply? 

I did use MA but I'm really not confident  to use Ma service anymore If im going for aat, I'm thinking to do it by myself with the help of my employer.

because using MA Didn't guarantee I'm getting the approval as well and it will cost so much.. 

it's just so much pressure since they are giving the 21 day limit decision making after waiting for 11 months...

1 hour ago, cristinamia said:

 

 

Hi.. my company is showing loss for 2 years as well but explainable and we showed 2-3 years forecast demonstrating recovery and revenue increase + tax accountant letter supporting the growth. I have not received any answer yet from them but I am hopeful. You could reapply for the nomination and add additional documents showing that despite the loss the company is operative and solvent. Many companies ( especially the ones part of groups under same shareholder) operate at a loss for tax reasons.

I did apply in the past to ATT because my 457 nomination was refused, but then I withdrew the application as I have resubmitted the nomination with further documents.

Hey guys anyone on nomination refusal due to financial loss? Facing decision if I should withdraw or apply for the aat? Need to make decision before my 21 days run out :(

is anyone has gone to att for this similar refusal? 

Hi Yu, I went to my agent today and thinking about the AAT but it's gonna cost me another 10k I really can't think right. 

@Sri0814 hi sri, Di you get your hearing date yet? Or if you already done the hearing could you please give an update how it goes? If u don't mind to share your experience 

Omg! After 1 year AAT and still nothing??!! I will be crazy as well like you.. during this 1 year AAT do u need to go for any hearing or court? But your 457 still active right?

Hi yuyu, your nomination refuse since 2017 and u apply for AAT until today you still haven't got any update?? I just got my refusal and thinking to apply for AAT... I'm really blank and can't think anymore 

@KKD& @sbrowne9 I got nomination refuse on Saturday. Because my company is making a loss now... I'm thinking for Applying AAT. But honestly I'm really don't know what to do... 

anyone apply aat after 186 refusal? 

On 14/05/2018 at 17:46, sbrowne9 said:

Hey @KKD....I had a nomination refusal too, it literally turned my world upside down; wont post details here, but safe to say a panic attack or two later, I reapplied. My only bit of advise would be step 1. take some time to leave it settle and think about things. Emotions are running high, and any decision may have a little spite/frustration in it. Is this where you want to be etc etc. then, if you think you can handle another application, step 2. go to a personal migration agent for a consultation if you havent already, not one associated with your employer. Get all your options, not just employer sponsored. 

I won't lie, the second application is harder...you know the possibility of a refusal, and it just adds to the anxiety of the wait. Feels like I've been waiting since last April!

Either way, if I or anyone else here can help, just let us know; also keep us informed, as your misfortune might be able to aid someone else in their application. Thats why the forum is here in my opinion; support and advice