Copied from PM i sent to Lynsey in reply:
in the end i managed to get some free advice from an immigration advisor, who said he wouldnt recommend me applying as i wouldnt meet the criteria. in his words everything is set in stone and if 1 aspect isnt matched you have no chance.
HOWEVER,
in my opinion there is a little bit of give and take, and i say that only from my experience applying for the same visa in NZ and with it being granted sucessfully (i am on that work visa now). If you are in an area which is quite inexperienced and is out of the city, for example in oz the job offer was in margaret river, small town, small population, 5 hours south of perth, your employer can claim how hard it is to find experienced people locally (proof with job adverts and local cvs) and the people which are qualified dont want to move down from the city.
i am currently in Gisborne, NZ and it is almost like margaret river but 10 years behind with a few more buildings! one visa requirement was qualifications in the hospo sector. as i said in my post i had none and have no intentions of going back to college to get one. but my employer made the case of how hard it is to find people good at hospo in the area, coupled with my previous experience and my visa came through in 1 week, no hiccups. I should also add that a couple of months before 'bar/cafe/restaraunt manager' was taken off the skill shortage list - which should have made my chances even slimmer.
i think one thing to remember is everyone who decides your visa is human. and if there is a few more questions to be asked your case officer will be in touch to discuss or request more info before making a descision.
I know that NZ and AUS are completely separate immigration controls but this is how my story faired in the end, and currently what im up to.
Im very interested to hear the outcome of your particular situation from what you told me Lyns. Please keep us updated. This is a big industry, but ive struggled to find personal experiences and info on the web from people applying for a visa in this type of front of house role.
All the best!