Vejay

Has anyone succeeded in appealing to (AAT) Tribunal willing to share your story?

On 27/05/2018 at 20:35, Tania said:

AAT also take ages. Currently on the website it said 449 days. But I saw one member in the forum submitted AAT Nov 2016, submitted requested docs in March 2018, AAT's result in May 2018, but lucky that no hearing needed. I think this is a very rare case.

All options take time, money and little hope ahead

Tania,

Thanks for the reply, Appreciated. We are planning to go for AAT at this stage, not sure what will be the outcome!

3 hours ago, Tania said:

My nomination had been refused without asking any documents after 7 months waiting. I am so upset.

There are 2 options for me to choose:

1. Withdraw my application so it will not be refused. Re-submit nomination with more supporting documents and re-submit new application. The new process will start all over again

2. Withdraw my application and appeal for nomination refusal

I don't understand Immi refused nomination without asking any information and without stating reasons in the refusal letter. By calling my Agent, they said they think my role is not needed. Then why they approved my 457 2 years ago?

Does anyone had the same experience?

 

The result of mine is same as yours. But mine got refused coz the training Benchmark did not pay at the right time and no additional information requested. My MA told my employer if he decided to withdraw the application, the application fee the immigration may and may not refund!!! Not sure if it is true? We are still considering whether go to AAT or withdraw !!!

Nomination and Visa Applied on 29-6-2017

Low risk country

Motor Mechanic

457 visa to 186 visa

Good day everyone,

Unfortunately after 11 months of waiting, my nomination has been refused due to the training benchmark did not pay for 2015 and 2018. Within the time-frame the department has not request any additional document from my Migration Agent, reason being of hiring a Migration Agent which determined their work are more professional. Decision of the department after their careful consideration finalized my nomination with ''refusal'', !!!straight-to-refusal!!! 

Reason for decision:

The Department’s acknowledgement letter put the nominator on notice that the Department may make a decision on this application without requesting additional information.

How fair is the decision! Any suggestion? Should I go for AAT, Lawyer, or does It even still worth to spend a single cents! Has anyone succeeded after AAT?