Viv L

27 minutes ago, MilaMocha said:

Hi Viv

Did the Agent mention going to the AAT? The waiting time is 1-2 years and gives plenty of time to build a strong case. This is, of course, if you believe the business will be profitable and can show this through financial statements. Your husband could also sign a new agreement with updated salary, if this was an issue.

Also, if they made the decision in 2018 they should have checked the 2017 and Jan-March 2018 financial reports. Your agent should have been uploading financial reports every 3 months to show the profitability, along with your husband’s payslips. A single report from 2016 is simply not good enough, it’s old information and doesn’t contribute to your case. Seems like not being updated regularly is what Immi used as a reason to refuse.

If you consider the ATT you might as well consider changing the Agent too.

Best of luck.

 

 

Hi MilaMocha,

Thank you for your replying.

Yes Immi did mention about refuse the nominations without asking more documents. 

Not sure about AAT because we are considering withdraw the187 DE application and apply 186 TRT if the financial from 2016 to 2018 are looks good. But I don’t know which option is better or what other options we can try..

our 457 will be expired in May 2019, Hopefully we still have some time to think about next step..

Hi guys,

I’ve watched this forum for a while, I gonna share my experience and also need some suggestion from you guys. 

My husband got 457 visa as restaurant manager in 2015, he transferred to the current employer and started to work in Jan,2016. Then he applied 187 DE on 30 June, after 21 months waiting, our nomination is refused on 28 March,2018..immi didn’t ask for more documents, they checked the 2015-2016 financial report from the owner, the reason immi refused the nomination was the financial is not strong enough and the labor cost seems not fair enough to pay all of staff. 

Our lawyer suggested us apply 186  translation. I’m wondering is it good for us to do this with the current employer ? 

We’re very disappointed and frustrated... I feel like it’s end of world for me.. hope someone could help us.. Thank you for reading, really appreciate. And good luck to someone still waiting.