Jump to content

You're currently viewing the forum as a Guest
register-now-button_orig.png
and join in with discussions   
ask migration questions
message other members


..and much much more!

leeroybrown

189 Visa refused

    Recommended Posts

    Hi everyone, a newbie here to this forum and forums in general so bear with me!

     

    My fiance and I applied for a 189 visa (her as a defacto) on 3rd Feb 2014 as an Architect from being on a 457 in Brisbane for the last 2.5 years. I had my skills assessed through AACA, had meds etc. Without any further correspondence until today (25th March 2014) I have been refused a visa based on the basis that I have provided an incorrect skills assessment.

     

    Now, apparently, the AACA have two different kinds of skills assessment - one that is for use as registration of an architect and one that is for the purpose of migration. I had no idea of this at the time and applied assuming that there is only this form of skills assessment. After my refusal, which both my fiance and I feel completely distraught about, I contact the AACA and they explained that if I sent them a stat dec stating why I needed the other certificate, they would send out the correct one.

     

    My problem is that my CO has 'finalised' the application and my EOI has been removed. The CO stated that as there was no valid skills assessment at the time the application was lodged then they can do no more on the visa apart from refuse it and finalise it. I have had no request for information during this process - if I had, then I could have supplied this, or withdrawn the application. As it stands I have lost the application fee, and either face a tribunal which will cost $1600 or re-apply for another visa with the correct skills assessment certificate which will cost another $4000 which we simply cannot afford as we have our wedding this year.

     

    Can anybody help with any advice? Is it worth to go to a tribunal with what I have described, providing I receive the correct skills assessment letter dated back when I received the other one? Could this situation be changed and not even go to a tribunal if I can get this information to my CO?

     

    My fiance and I are completely floored by this news and can't believe that something like this can happen without any correspondence from them in the interim.

     

    If anybody requires more info, just ask and I will let you know what I can. Any advice would be appreciated - especially advice which won't cost us any more money!

    Share this post


    Link to post
    Share on other sites
    Moneycorp

    Moneycorp

    Unfortunately your co could do nothing else. They are the rules. Going to the mrt is useless as you didn't fit the basic criteria at time of application.

     

    I know they are expensive, but this is why so many people use migration agents, as there are stupid little oddities which can trip you up.

    If I were you I'd just apply again.


    Has two beautiful Aussie little girls :-)

    Share this post


    Link to post
    Share on other sites

    I am surprised you did not get any contact before the refusal to be honest, because there was always the possibility you simply attached the wrong document and really had the correct skills assessment in your possession all along? Is skills assessment very similar to whatever assessment you did have? If so and if AACA were willing to back date a skills assessment letter on that basis, you might have just swung it, would they have backdated it?

     

    Also are you sure you did not get forewarning? And was this latest correspondence definitely the refusal, not notice of refusal? Note that withdrawing an application would not have resulted in money back, it just would save you the record of having had a visa refusal. That will be a pain in the butt now forever more now as you will have to keep declaring it when you travel and will get pulled over to explain etc.

     

    I certainly would not consider an MRT unless you can come up with a skills assessment that pre dates your EOI. Even then I would only consider that if you take some professional help, MRT is not a do it yourself area.

     

    If you don't have and cannot get a skills assessment that predates your EOI, then you need to take this on the chin. Unfortunately we all lose money on something at some point in our lives and this could be it for you. Pick yourself up, dust yourself down and try again.

    Share this post


    Link to post
    Share on other sites
    I am surprised you did not get any contact before the refusal to be honest, because there was always the possibility you simply attached the wrong document and really had the correct skills assessment in your possession all along? Is skills assessment very similar to whatever assessment you did have? If so and if AACA were willing to back date a skills assessment letter on that basis, you might have just swung it, would they have backdated it?

     

    Also are you sure you did not get forewarning? And was this latest correspondence definitely the refusal, not notice of refusal? Note that withdrawing an application would not have resulted in money back, it just would save you the record of having had a visa refusal. That will be a pain in the butt now forever more now as you will have to keep declaring it when you travel and will get pulled over to explain etc.

     

    I certainly would not consider an MRT unless you can come up with a skills assessment that pre dates your EOI. Even then I would only consider that if you take some professional help, MRT is not a do it yourself area.

     

    If you don't have and cannot get a skills assessment that predates your EOI, then you need to take this on the chin. Unfortunately we all lose money on something at some point in our lives and this could be it for you. Pick yourself up, dust yourself down and try again.

     

    Hi Rupert,

     

    I have just received the correct Skills Assessment back from the AACA, my Skills Assessment body. They have backdated it to 23rd July 2013 which was the time I originally applied for the skills assessment, believing that was the one to supply to Immigration for migration purposes. I have a Stat Dec to back that up and a covering letter from the AACA which explains that the process for skills assessment for both outcomes is exactly the same process - it is just the final document which states "for migration purposes" or "for registration as an architect".

     

    Surely this will prove that at the time of my EOI and visa application, I had a valid Skills Assessment. I have contacted my CO over email and she states that because it was a lawful decision, she cannot revisit the application. I have also spoken on the phone to her manager who gave me a very similar reply.

     

    I find it ridiculous that something so simple, such as contacting me to request the correct document which I have shown that I can supply relatively quickly, could have been actioned and would save Immigration the time in the long run and save me another $5,200 in a new application or at least $1,600 in MRT fees plus legal fees!

     

    Is there nobody that will use some common sense rather than get lost in policies which are clearly flawed? Where does discretion feature in all off this? My fiancee and I are so angry about this outcome as it seems nobody can do anything about this matter, so if any of you guys are Immigration lawyers, or if you know of anyone that can help then please let us know.

    Share this post


    Link to post
    Share on other sites

    It isn't an issue of flawed policies. You didn't meet the criteria set out in the legislation. The case officer cannot exercise a discretion.

     

    Lodge another application - it is the quickest solution.

     

    Best regards.


    Managing Director, Go Matilda Visas, www.gomatilda.com - Principal, bdh Tax, www.bdhtax.com

    Registered Migration Agent Number 0102534, Chartered Accountant (England & Wales, and Australia), and Registered Tax Agent (Australia)

    T - 023 81 66 11 55 (UK) or 03 9935 2929 (Australia)

    E - alan.collett@gomatilda.com

    Share this post


    Link to post
    Share on other sites
    Posted (edited)
    On 25/3/2014 at 22:45, leeroybrown said:

    Hi everyone, a newbie here to this forum and forums in general so bear with me!

     

    My fiance and I applied for a 189 visa (her as a defacto) on 3rd Feb 2014 as an Architect from being on a 457 in Brisbane for the last 2.5 years. I had my skills assessed through AACA, had meds etc. Without any further correspondence until today (25th March 2014) I have been refused a visa based on the basis that I have provided an incorrect skills assessment.

     

    Now, apparently, the AACA have two different kinds of skills assessment - one that is for use as registration of an architect and one that is for the purpose of migration. I had no idea of this at the time and applied assuming that there is only this form of skills assessment. After my refusal, which both my fiance and I feel completely distraught about, I contact the AACA and they explained that if I sent them a stat dec stating why I needed the other certificate, they would send out the correct one.

     

    My problem is that my CO has 'finalised' the application and my EOI has been removed. The CO stated that as there was no valid skills assessment at the time the application was lodged then they can do no more on the visa apart from refuse it and finalise it. I have had no request for information during this process - if I had, then I could have supplied this, or withdrawn the application. As it stands I have lost the application fee, and either face a tribunal which will cost $1600 or re-apply for another visa with the correct skills assessment certificate which will cost another $4000 which we simply cannot afford as we have our wedding this year.

     

    Can anybody help with any advice? Is it worth to go to a tribunal with what I have described, providing I receive the correct skills assessment letter dated back when I received the other one? Could this situation be changed and not even go to a tribunal if I can get this information to my CO?

     

    My fiance and I are completely floored by this news and can't believe that something like this can happen without any correspondence from them in the interim.

     

    If anybody requires more info, just ask and I will let you know what I can. Any advice would be appreciated - especially advice which won't cost us any more money!

    Hello leeroybrow,

    I am very sorry to hear what happened to you! I am an architect and going to submit my EOI, and your story scares me alot. 

    Could you please tell me what was the outcome and if you have applied (and finally being granted) a new visa?

    I am currently sponsored as 'Architect' but and I am not yet a registered Architect here in Australia (therefore my position on my letter of employment does not state 'Architect'); also, I have the AACA assessment stage 1 'for migration purpose'.

    May I ask what position you were at the company that sponsored you (the same that you should have used in the visa application)? 

    I am starting to be a bit confused whether I can apply for 189 visa as an Architect (and claiming 5 point for +1 year OZ employement), not being technically an australian registered one yet.

    Any suggestion would be greatly appreciated.

    Thanks,

    Edited by joygreek

    Share this post


    Link to post
    Share on other sites

    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now


    • Similar Content

      • By anthonyd
        Hi all,

        I have received an invite for 189 and want to apply for visa asap.
        However, I just left Australia for a longer trip. My partner is still in Australia during this time, though she will visit me abroad during my trip.

        Question:
        If I apply for 189 while being outside of Australia, will my partner get a bridging visa if she is in Australia during my application? 

        I do not really need a bridging visa, since I hold e-visitor visa and can stay in AU up to 3 months at a time. I do travel often anyway, so I can easily just use my current visa until I get 189.
        My partner, however, holds a visa that expires soon, so for her getting bridging visa is very important.

        Ideally I want to apply while offshore, then come to Australia on my e-visitor visa to stay with my partner. 
        Will she get a bridging visa if she is in Australia during application, but I am not in the country?

        Thanks.
      • By lewisant48
        Hey everybody. I've looked all through the forum archives to try and find an answer to my query so i didn't have to start a new thread but i've had no joy.
        You get points for qualifications, but do the qualifications have to be relevant to the occupation? My girlfriend will be the primary applicant as veterinary nurse but she has a BA Degree in Textiles - will that degree get her further points or does she have to use the qualification attached to vet nursing? it's much lesser and will give less points.
        Thanks, Lewis
      • By lifegoeson
        Hi,   Just have a query with regards to my eligibility to apply for the 189 Visa as a NZ citizen.     I moved to Australia from NZ in Sept 2009 and worked up until August 2016. I fall within the threshold of the income category. I quit my job in 2016 and have been travelling every since and will only be back in Australia in June 2018.   I still have a property in Aus and that is where my home is. As I have been away for over an year now , will I still be eligible to apply for PR under the 189 Visa? https://www.border.gov.au/Trav/Visa-1/189-new-zealand-stream   Will my absence away from Aus on holiday deny me the approval for the visa?   Thanking you in advance. 
      • By Purplesparkle
        Hi all,
         
        We have today had our medicals uploaded and no further action needed :cool:. We have uploaded our police check certificates and submitted the additional information that was requested by our CO. So now I guess the wait begins for them to get back to us for more info or if we will get our visa granted :err:. Has anyone else submitted and are waiting to hear back? Here's hoping it isn't too longer wait to find out the outcome!
         
        Purplesparkle x
      • By strayadreams
        Hi everyone,
        So, I can't help but notice that October grants are well below the usual grant rate? I know September was a massive month (one of the trackers reporting as many as 270 PR grants in the month) much more than the usual, but so far in October less than a handful. Does anyone know why this might be? Even if you don't include September its still way below the average. I could make some assumptions about why but, if anyone has more experience or has some information that would be great!
    ×