Thank's for the reply .The first time I applied I wrote ; we needed to go back as my Brother-in -law is ill and I need to support my sister ,but did not include much detail. Yesterday I wrote ; We wish to return Permanently to the UK and attached a copy of my spouse's approved returning PR visa , which expires May 9th, We have even considered renouncing citizenship ,but I'm not sure if that would allow us to leave.? Thanks Again.