Absolutely spot on. However there is no consistency my son is on an apprenticeship, which I argued is education to get his qualification, he is earning less than a student bar maid but does not qualify as a dependant. Obviously it's close to my heart as he is my child and it was me who withdrew him from the application, before they declined him. It's now history but hopefully others can learn from my experience. We will all go to Oz. The worst that can happen after 12 months, if they can't stay, we all come home.