Go Back   PomsInOz Forum > Forum > Lounge Room > Migration Issues

Notices

Migration Issues Discuss all aspects about migrating to Australia and the visa process


Reply
 
Thread Tools
Old 08-03-2008, 03:00 PM   #1 (permalink)
Moderator
 
Gollywobbler's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Southampton, UK
Posts: 6,132
Thanks: 49
Thanked 188 Times in 142 Posts
My Mood:
Gollywobbler has much to be proud ofGollywobbler has much to be proud ofGollywobbler has much to be proud ofGollywobbler has much to be proud ofGollywobbler has much to be proud ofGollywobbler has much to be proud ofGollywobbler has much to be proud ofGollywobbler has much to be proud ofGollywobbler has much to be proud of
Contributory Parent Visa - Comment

Hi All

Some of the members of PiO (and silent watchers of PiO) are also following the Contributory Parent Visa threads on British Expats and other forums.

I do myself, and I am a bit concerned about the posts on there at pages 37 & 38 of the main thread on this topic, started by Sleeping Beauty. Please see here:

the ALL NEW SPARKLY contributory parents visa thread!!! - Page 38 : British Expat Discussion Forum

Leaving aside Lance Fee's article, because he is not saying anything new, I am concerned about people being encouraged to try to get Centrelink to give the AoS Bond payments back temporarily.

It is a fair bet that the machinery to do that does not exist at all (unless the visa applicant dies between now and 1st July 2008) and even if any other machinery does exist it would not work fast, that is for sure.

Much more importantly, I suggest, in the unlikely event that someone might succeed in claiming the Bond back, an inevitable consequence of it would be that that Centrelink would have to inform DIAC that the Assurance of Support is no longer in place for the Contributory Parent Visa applicant(s) in question.

My firm advice to anyone reading Poms in Oz is, "DO NOT rock the Centrelink boat at this stage." Don't even think about it because it has all the potential to cause chaos with your application and chaos would in turn cause delays, without doubt.

Bicker with Centrelink and the Bank after the visas have been granted and the applicants have moved to Oz. At that point, shout in the Minister's ear too because somebody is earning hidden interest on these wedges of money, and it was never intended by policy or by the legislation that the Commonwealth Bank should keep the money in its clutches for extra periods of time.

At the very worst there is now only a few weeks to go before things are likely to start happening with regard to the payments of the 2nd Instalments for those applicants who have already completed their AOS arrangements.

A far more fruitful question, I reckon, is for somebody to ask the POPC exactly when they intend to start calling for the 2nd Instalment in the cases of applicants such as Caz Beckham (just to use you as an illustration, Caz.)

I do not believe that they have to wait till July 1st before they request the money and I don't think they will do so. I would expect to see the POPC asking for the 2nd instalments at least 6 weeks before 1st July, so that the visas can be granted as soon as the POPC opens for business on 1st July.

Fortunately,1st July 2008 is a Tuesday. Therefore they will have all day on Monday to prepare for the most immediate grants.

But I would repeat to anyone who has gone through the Centrelink process to leave Centrelink firmly out of this debate and out of any possible action at this stage.

Best wishes

Gill

Gollywobbler is online now  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote

Sponsors
Old 08-03-2008, 03:50 PM   #2 (permalink)
Member
 
Marilyn's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Scottish Borders
Posts: 57
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Marilyn is on a distinguished road
Hi Gilly

Just read your posting. Last week you suggested it would be end September before everything would be in place for cp visas. If I have understood you correctly you now think the second installment will be requested 6 weeks before 1 July so does this mean we can hope to be ready to go before end September or is my impatience showing?

Marilyn
Marilyn is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 08-03-2008, 06:19 PM   #3 (permalink)
Moderator
 
Gollywobbler's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Southampton, UK
Posts: 6,132
Thanks: 49
Thanked 188 Times in 142 Posts
My Mood:
Gollywobbler has much to be proud ofGollywobbler has much to be proud ofGollywobbler has much to be proud ofGollywobbler has much to be proud ofGollywobbler has much to be proud ofGollywobbler has much to be proud ofGollywobbler has much to be proud ofGollywobbler has much to be proud ofGollywobbler has much to be proud of
Hi Marilyn

Quote:
Just under 3 weeks ago, the POPC said that they have about 1,000 applicants in the same position as you - ie the meds & police have been cleared and the application is now in the Queue. The person who rang them (who then gave me the update) spoke with the Assistant Manager of the POPC.

She told the enquirer that visas out of the 3,500 which will be available from 1st July 2008 onwards have been reserved for all of the 1000 applicants currently in the Queue.

Since you are clearly one of them, I reckon that you could have your visa by the end of September, realistically, because the Assurance of Support drills with Centrelink can take time and so can making the second payment etc.
That was 4 weeks ago now.

Some of the applicants (eg Caz) have nothing left to do now except pay the 2nd Instalment.

Caz happens to be using a particularly experienced, efficient and effective Agent called Alan Collett of Go Matilda. Alan knows every which way of getting money to the POPC and getting a visa out of them fast in return.

Plus, rather more - or perhaps less - prosaically, since Alan is aware that Caz & I will both kill him unless her CPV is granted on Tuesday 1st July 2008 at the very latest, I feel sure that a personal desire on his part to survive the Monstrous Regiment of Women will convince him to find a way to make it happen!

Seriously, though, the POPC have said that they will do their level best not to delay CPV grants once they have some more visas to grant. One way they can do that is to ask for Caz's money for the 2nd Instalment in plenty of time to get it off deposit and/or shares sold etc.

Similarly, with applicants like you who are further behind in the process, I don't see any reason to wait till on or after 1st July before asking you to get the ball rolling with Centrelink if you are applying for the CP 143 visa?

If you are applying for the CP 173, you will not have to risk hold-ups with Centrelink at this stage.

However, all other things being even, it is only fair that the POPC should consider the amount of meds clearance time left on the various applications (particularly when the meds were not done until requested.) It wouldn't be fair to give Caz 3 months to get to Oz in order to validate her visa but to give you 9 months or so, would it?

The current Manager of the POPC is an immensely nice man who is very committed to Parents and really does understand the anguish that families feel about Parent visas. He is also very fair minded plus loaded with common sense. He's a good man.

He will get these visas granted as quickly and as fairly as he possibly can, I reckon.

Centrelink (in Perth where my sister and Mum are) were dire, however. Dire. No other word for it. If Elaine (my sister) and I had left it to them the AoS process would have taken 3 months for sure with Mum's visa. Elaine & I set about Centrelink and made their lives a such a misery every day until they just wanted to get rid of both of us fast that they astounded themselves with how fast they can move once it is demonstrated to them that no other option is on offer. Below the belt maybe. Effective nevertheless!

Best wishes

Gill
Gollywobbler is online now  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 09-03-2008, 03:27 AM   #4 (permalink)
Junior Member
 
sleeping beauty's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 3
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
sleeping beauty is on a distinguished road
hello, my first post on here and i am defending myself!

at no point in any of my posts on BE have i mentioned getting the AOS bond returned from Centrelink. surely this is pointless as it would cause more time being wasted re-lodging the bond. please read what i have written carefully before mis-quoting me on other forums.

i have stated that it is not right that there are a few CPV applicants who has parted company with $14,000 (for 2 people), quite some months ago (my parents bond was lodged in october 2007). which i think, if you were in their shoes, you too would feel agrieved.

incidentally, i have had a letter in reply to my letter sent to Chris Evans, advising that ".......your parents assurer may wish to withdraw th AoS bond. They can contact Centrelink and request release of the bond prior to visa grant. your parents assurer would then be required to lodge the AoS again at a later date, which may further delay processing for visa grant consideration...............".

so, it can be done, but who the hell in their right mind would do that?

once again, please do not mis-quote me and get your facts right.
sleeping beauty is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 09-03-2008, 11:10 AM   #5 (permalink)
Moderator
 
Gollywobbler's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Southampton, UK
Posts: 6,132
Thanks: 49
Thanked 188 Times in 142 Posts
My Mood:
Gollywobbler has much to be proud ofGollywobbler has much to be proud ofGollywobbler has much to be proud ofGollywobbler has much to be proud ofGollywobbler has much to be proud ofGollywobbler has much to be proud ofGollywobbler has much to be proud ofGollywobbler has much to be proud ofGollywobbler has much to be proud of
Hello Sleeping Beauty

Welcome to Poms in Oz.

Nobody is attacking you or has tried to do so, least of all me. One the contrary, I have been doing everything I can to try to get up to date information as and when there is any and to make sure that that information is disseminated in order to try to help people like your own family amongst many others.

Quote:
incidentally, i have had a letter in reply to my letter sent to Chris Evans, advising that ".......your parents assurer may wish to withdraw th AoS bond. They can contact Centrelink and request release of the bond prior to visa grant. your parents assurer would then be required to lodge the AoS again at a later date, which may further delay processing for visa grant consideration...............".
I am aware that this is the what the Minister's acoloytes have told a couple of people who have phoned the Minister's office complaining about the delays. The Minister's own information appears to be out of date (or that of his minions is) because the legislation was tweaked earlier this year and the result is that whereas in the past an Assurer could back out of an AoS once given, this is no longer the case. You will find the relevant provisions in the latest amendments to the Social Security Act 1991, I would think.

What with people complaining about the interest on the money, and suggestions by another of your contributors that applicants might want to complain to DIAC or to the Ombudsman, it is but a short step for somebody to think of contacting Centrelink and trying to unstitch the AoS temporarily. "Someone" many not even be a contributor to your thread or to Poms in Oz. Far more people read these threads than make any contribution to them. The ones who actually post anything on them are in a minority, I reckon, when one considers the number of hits on the various CPV threads.

You & I are trying to fight the same wicket of trying to keep everyone safe, informed and to get their visas granted as quickly as possible. I applaud your own efforts to the hilt. It is a pity, perhaps, that you seem to feel less gracious about my own identical efforts.

What the readers of other forums do is no concern of mine but I do not want readers of Poms in Oz to imagine that trying to bust the AoS temporarily would be a sensible step to take at this juncture because I believe that it would be completely counter-productive. Complaining to Centrelink would not help either because they only did what DIAC asked them to do. This is DIAC's own fiasco and nobody else is responsible for it..

If you search through the posts on here by me, you will discover that I have referred numerous CPV applicants (and those who are waiting till they can apply) to the BE CPV threads in order to let them know that there are plenty of sources of information available to them besides those which they can discover from reading BE. Why would I plug your threads publicly if I thought they were misleading rubbish?

Trust me, when these visas are eventually granted to the people like your own Parents, I shall join the clamour to get something done about ensuring that this situation does not happen again, and where Meds have to be done twice for members of the current group, I will join any campaign going to try to force DIAC to re-imburse the Parents for the money effectively wasted on getting the first lot of meds done - at DIAC's request - just before DIAC suddenly shifted the goalposts on all the applicants without a word of prior warning to any of them.

They have still not managed to put an "information strategy" into place about it either, some 3.5 months after they suddenly decided to implement the formal Queueing procedure. It seems they decided to start the Queue business during the first week in December and to do so with immediate effect, leaving many people like your own Parents "caught on the cusp" as it were. The website is still insisting that there is no Queue:

Parent Visa Processing Priorities - Family - Visas & Immigration

Why didn't they count the number of visas they had left much sooner than they seemingly did, so as to ensure that nobody would be caught on the cusp in this way? Commonsense (I would have thought) is to reserve the visas at the time when the CO first makes contact, not later on in the game. If the applicant subsequently dies/fails the meds or whatever, the "spare" visa can always go back into the pot, but not to reserve it before triggering costs on the applicant's part in the shape of meds etc seems short-sighted to me.

Personally I think the buck for all this stops with the head of DIAC's Family Section. None of it the fault of the foot soldiers at the POPC. I think that Canberra has mis-managed the whole thing, frankly, and feeble tales about a change of Government is not a viable excuse for inefficiency and mismanagement by any Civil Service Department. They are supposed to keep the balls rolling even if the Parliament building burns down and takes all the Ministers with it.

However, I am sure that I will not be alone in composing a suitably pithy letter about all this after the current group of applicants including your own Parents have their visas safely. I could be complaining to the Minister, the Ombudsman, the DIAC complaints team, Centrelink, Federal MPS and Uncle Tom Cobley & All but I am not prepared to do or say anything which might help to trigger an Inquiry that might simply hold everything up at this delicate stage.

Incidentally, a guy who is not a contributor to either BE or Poms in Oz was kind enough to contact me recently. I think he and his wife received their CPVs in about May 2007. They now live in South Australia. He told me that since he and his wife are over 65 or whatever the relevant age is, they were given "Seniors Cards" as soon as they moved to SA. Apparently these cards enable them to get discounts in cinemas, on public transport, in restaurants, the hairdresser etc. He says they were told that it is SA's policy to issue these cards without imposing any sort of qualifying period for them, nd the official in SA said that s/he thought this is not necessarily the practice in all States.

I am not sure whether this is some sort of Card that is peculiar to SA. Before Mum's visa was granted in 2006, I tried to investigate the concessionary cards offered by Centrelink - though I am in the UK so I had to try to play Chinese Whispers with them via my sister in Perth.

First they gave Elaine a Form. They told her a yarn about completing this form and giving it to Centrelink as soon as Mum moved to Oz, claiming that it would take two years for them to get the necessary confirmation from DIAC. Which is nonsense. Surely the stamps in the person's passport provide all and any evidence that Centrelink need? Also DIAC would be in breach of their own Charter Service Standards if they took two years to come up with any necessary information, so this claim is difficult to believe. The form is on the Centrelink website somewhere but I can't remember which bit. It seems to be something to do with the two year qualifying period during which new migrants are not entitled to these Australian concessions.

The stuff about the Cards appears to be here:

A - Z Directory

It is not something that is recoverable from the Bond (the details of the Recoverable Benefits are listed under Assurance of Support, with details of each one, and I have been through that with a fine toothcomb.) Nothing relating to Health is recoverable from the Bond either.

Mum's income may be too high for any of these concessions anyway but as yet I have not investigated it closely because until I heard from the CPV holder in SA, I thought that there must be a two-year qualifying period and Mum has not lived there for 2 years as yet.

However, if Mum is eligible for one of these cards then we intend to get her one as soon as we can because anything which does not compromise the Bond but which can help to offset the reduction in the UK State Pension is worth it, I reckon, even if it only means 10% off at the hairdresser each week.

Having said that, Mum is in Perth and I believe that your Parents will be moving to either QLD or NSW? I could be on completely the wrong track in thinking that this is anything to do with Centrelink. It might be a different concession entirely, administered by the State Government in each State.

Finding out about this in relation to WA is on the "to do" list, but you do not need me to describe how long that always is! Also, SA is keen to attract new migrants so this could be a purely local incentive - I don't know. I mention it in case you want to try to investigate it for your own Parents if they are old enough to be potential candiates for it.

However, I am certain that you and I are absolutely on the same side in the same team in trying to do our best for our own Parents and all other CPV holders and applicants. Therefore we should be working together on all this instead of your trying to take potshots at me, I suggest.

Best wishes

Gill
Gollywobbler is online now  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 09-03-2008, 12:16 PM   #6 (permalink)
Junior Member
 
sleeping beauty's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 3
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
sleeping beauty is on a distinguished road
gill, what you are saying is all guess work.

What with people complaining about the interest on the money, and suggestions by another of your contributors that applicants might want to complain to DIAC or to the Ombudsman, it is but a short step for somebody to think of contacting Centrelink and trying to unstitch the AoS temporarily. "Someone" many not even be a contributor to your thread or to Poms in Oz. Far more people read these threads than make any contribution to them. The ones who actually post anything on them are in a minority, I reckon, when one considers the number of hits on the various CPV threads.

..............but it is still a short step, and NOBODY has suggested it. YOU have mentioned it, nobody else, so you have put that thought into peoples heads, nobody else.

you have also mentioned............

At the very worst there is now only a few weeks to go before things are likely to start happening with regard to the payments of the 2nd Instalments for those applicants who have already completed their AOS arrangements.

A far more fruitful question, I reckon, is for somebody to ask the POPC exactly when they intend to start calling for the 2nd Instalment in the cases of applicants such as Caz Beckham (just to use you as an illustration, Caz.)

I do not believe that they have to wait till July 1st before they request the money and I don't think they will do so. I would expect to see the POPC asking for the 2nd instalments at least 6 weeks before 1st July, so that the visas can be granted as soon as the POPC opens for business on 1st July.


...........this would be good if it did indeed happen, but where is this little snippet of info from? or is it guesswork again? facts are needed, not guessing what is going to happen.

i do not advise people what to do or not what to do, my parents are my concern, and i do not guess online what is going to happen. i believe that nothing will happen at all until 01jul08 at the very earliest, maybe even a few days after that date, but this is my belief, and i havent tried to impose my personal guesswork onto other posters/lurkers.

our priority is for our parents to get their visa. what happens once they get here is a long way off, but thank you for your information. once they get their visa granted, then great. in the meantime we wait, along with everybody else. but, we can moan about it if we want to.
sleeping beauty is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 09-03-2008, 12:26 PM   #7 (permalink)
Moderator
 
johatts's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Brisbane
Posts: 3,262
Blog Entries: 6
Thanks: 166
Thanked 148 Times in 91 Posts
My Mood:
johatts has a brilliant futurejohatts has a brilliant futurejohatts has a brilliant futurejohatts has a brilliant futurejohatts has a brilliant futurejohatts has a brilliant futurejohatts has a brilliant futurejohatts has a brilliant futurejohatts has a brilliant futurejohatts has a brilliant futurejohatts has a brilliant future
Quote:
Originally Posted by sleeping beauty View Post
, my parents are my concern, .
Surely this is the bottom line and the most important thing in all of this. We all have to wait until July 1st - there is nothing we can do!

My parents paid their bond in December, I was sorting out the AOS a week before Christmas!

Lets keep the parents the focus of this thread instead of *** for tatting against each other!
__________________
Joanne & Mark
Countdown to Christmas.......24 days
johatts is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 09-03-2008, 12:55 PM   #8 (permalink)
Moderator
 
Gollywobbler's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Southampton, UK
Posts: 6,132
Thanks: 49
Thanked 188 Times in 142 Posts
My Mood:
Gollywobbler has much to be proud ofGollywobbler has much to be proud ofGollywobbler has much to be proud ofGollywobbler has much to be proud ofGollywobbler has much to be proud ofGollywobbler has much to be proud ofGollywobbler has much to be proud ofGollywobbler has much to be proud ofGollywobbler has much to be proud of
Quote:
...........this would be good if it did indeed happen, but where is this little snippet of info from? or is it guesswork again? facts are needed, not guessing what is going to happen.
Why don't you ring them and ask them, SB? Ask for the Manager, I suggest. I think you are likely to find that my hunch is probably right.

Best wishes

Gill
Gollywobbler is online now  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 09-03-2008, 09:20 PM   #9 (permalink)
Junior Member
 
sleeping beauty's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 3
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
sleeping beauty is on a distinguished road
no thanks, 01jul08 is what both my parents and my siblings and i and looking at. if anything happens before, great, but like cazbeckham says who wants to rock boats at this stage? speculation and second guessing wont do anyone any favours.
sleeping beauty is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 10-03-2008, 07:39 AM   #10 (permalink)
Moderator
 
johatts's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Brisbane
Posts: 3,262
Blog Entries: 6
Thanks: 166
Thanked 148 Times in 91 Posts
My Mood:
johatts has a brilliant futurejohatts has a brilliant futurejohatts has a brilliant futurejohatts has a brilliant futurejohatts has a brilliant futurejohatts has a brilliant futurejohatts has a brilliant futurejohatts has a brilliant futurejohatts has a brilliant futurejohatts has a brilliant futurejohatts has a brilliant future
[quote=sleeping beauty;201272], 01jul08 is what both my parents and i are looking at. if anything happens before, great [quote]

Thats exactly the way I am thinking too. CazBeckham is my mum!!!! We are having work done on our house so she cant come before then cos it wont be finished!
__________________
Joanne & Mark
Countdown to Christmas.......24 days


johatts is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote

Sponsors
Reply

Bookmarks


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are Off
Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Contributory Parent Visa randpm Migration Issues 52 15-11-2008 09:20 AM
Contributory Parent visa Lanky Lad Brits In Oz 2 29-02-2008 01:50 PM
how long for contributory 143 parent visa? Julie Fairway Migration Issues 1 21-01-2008 02:33 PM
Contributory Parent Visa??? or other? help? Hayley370 Migration Issues 1 29-08-2007 04:45 AM
Contributory Parent Visa Granted Gollywobbler News, Gossip & Chat 31 30-10-2006 11:12 PM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 06:37 AM.